top of page
The Great Conversation

The Great Conversation: Can Technology Ever Be More Secure Than the Humans Who Control It?

Nov 9
5 min read
The Great Conversation

Hello everyone, and welcome to The Great Conversation.


When we think about protecting the world's most advanced technology, we tend to imagine equally advanced threats.


Hackers breaking through computer networks.


Malware infiltrating secure systems.


Cyberattacks targeting data centers.


Governments attempting to steal closely guarded technological secrets.


But sometimes the path into one of the world's most important technology companies may begin with something considerably older than computers.


A human relationship.


A recent Telegraph article examines allegations surrounding Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang and Alice Huang, an executive whom U.S. intelligence reportedly suspected of having links to Chinese intelligence.


The allegations have attracted attention partly because Nvidia is not simply another technology company.


Its advanced chips have become central to the artificial intelligence revolution.


That makes knowledge about the company's technology, strategy and operations extraordinarily valuable.


The United States and China are competing intensely over advanced semiconductors and artificial intelligence.


Governments are restricting access to certain technologies.


Companies are protecting intellectual property.


Intelligence agencies are watching competitors.


Billions of dollars are being invested in cybersecurity.


And yet the controversy raises an uncomfortable possibility.


What if the weakest point in an extraordinarily sophisticated technological system is not technological at all?


What if it is human?


Espionage has understood this possibility for centuries.


Long before computers existed, intelligence services learned that information could be obtained by understanding the people who possessed it.


Their ambitions.


Their fears.


Their relationships.


Their financial problems.


Their desire for recognition.


Their loneliness.


Their secrets.


Their trust.


Technology changes.


Human psychology changes much more slowly.


This is why intelligence operations have historically relied not only on surveillance and technical infiltration but also on human relationships.


Friendship can create access.


Romance can create intimacy.


Money can create incentives.


Ideology can create loyalty.


Fear can create compliance.


And secrets can create leverage.


The modern term "social engineering" sounds technological.


But the underlying idea is ancient.


Instead of attacking the machine, you influence the person operating the machine.


Someone can build an extraordinarily secure computer system and still receive a convincing message from someone they trust.


A company can encrypt its most sensitive information and still have an employee reveal something during an apparently harmless conversation.


An organization can require passwords, authentication systems and security clearances while someone with legitimate access is being manipulated.


The security system may function exactly as designed.


The human being may simply open the door.


And artificial intelligence could make this problem even more complicated.


AI can help detect suspicious behavior.


It can analyze enormous amounts of security data.


It can identify unusual network activity.


It can help organizations recognize cyberattacks faster.


But AI can also make deception more sophisticated.


A convincing email can be generated instantly.


A person's writing style can be imitated.


Voices can be cloned.


Images can be fabricated.


Video can be manipulated.


Large amounts of public information about an individual can be analyzed to create highly personalized attempts at persuasion.


The traditional phishing message was often easy to recognize.


Poor grammar.


Strange wording.


An obviously suspicious request.


But imagine an attempted deception created specifically for you.


It knows where you work.


It understands your profession.


It knows the conferences you attend.


It knows the people in your field.


It understands how those people communicate.


Perhaps it even sounds like someone you know.


At that point, cybersecurity becomes something more than protecting computers.


It becomes the protection of human judgment.


And judgment is difficult to secure.


A computer can be programmed never to reveal a password.


A human being must constantly interpret context.


Is this person trustworthy?


Is this message legitimate?


Is this relationship genuine?


Is this request unusual?


Am I being manipulated?


Those questions do not have simple technical answers.


Because trust itself is essential to human society.


We cannot eliminate vulnerability simply by eliminating trust.


Businesses depend on trust.


Governments depend on trust.


Scientific collaboration depends on trust.


Families depend on trust.


Friendships depend on trust.


Human relationships depend on trust.


A society in which everyone assumes everyone else is attempting to manipulate them might become more difficult to deceive.


It would also become almost impossible to live in.


So security faces a paradox.


We need trust in order to cooperate.


But trust creates the possibility of betrayal.


The more sensitive someone's position becomes, the more consequential that possibility can become.


A casual conversation involving an ordinary employee may reveal very little.


A casual conversation involving someone near the center of an important technological company could reveal considerably more.


This is why organizations attempt to compartmentalize information.


Not everyone needs access to everything.


Security clearances exist partly because institutions recognize that protecting information requires controlling who can reach it.


But even compartmentalization cannot eliminate human vulnerability.


Because eventually someone must know something.


Someone must operate the system.


Someone must make the decision.


Someone must possess the password.


Someone must have access.


And wherever access exists, trust exists.


Perhaps this is the deeper lesson behind espionage scandals.


Security is never purely technological.


It is technological, institutional and psychological at the same time.


The strongest encryption in the world cannot protect information that someone voluntarily reveals.


The most advanced surveillance system cannot perfectly determine someone's intentions.


And the most sophisticated artificial intelligence cannot eliminate the complexity of human relationships.


In fact, the more powerful our technology becomes, the more valuable the humans surrounding that technology may become as targets.


A century ago, an intelligence service might have wanted access to military plans.


Today it might want semiconductor designs.


AI research.


Algorithms.


Training methods.


Supply chains.


Corporate strategy.


Scientific discoveries.


The object of espionage changes with civilization.


The human doorway remains remarkably familiar.


And there is another uncomfortable dimension to this.


We often imagine technological progress as replacing human weakness.


Machines calculate better.


Computers remember more.


AI analyzes information faster.


Automation reduces human error.


But technological progress can also magnify the consequences of human error.


One compromised person in an ordinary organization may cause limited damage.


One compromised person with access to enormously powerful technology may affect companies, governments or even geopolitical competition.


So perhaps technological progress does not eliminate human vulnerability.


It increases the importance of understanding it.


That means cybersecurity education may increasingly need to include psychology.


Organizations may need to think not only about networks but relationships.


Not only about malware but manipulation.


Not only about passwords but persuasion.


Not only about who can access information but how those people might be influenced.


And individuals occupying sensitive positions may have to understand something uncomfortable about themselves:


Being intelligent does not make someone immune to manipulation.


Being successful does not make someone immune.


Being technically sophisticated does not make someone immune.


Human vulnerabilities are not necessarily signs of stupidity.


They often emerge from ordinary human needs.


Trust.


Affection.


Belonging.


Recognition.


Curiosity.


Ambition.


Desire.


Fear.


The very qualities that make relationships possible can sometimes make manipulation possible.


Which means the ultimate security problem may never be completely solvable.


We can improve systems.


We can create safeguards.


We can educate people.


We can restrict access.


We can monitor suspicious activity.


We can use artificial intelligence to defend against artificial intelligence.


But eventually every security system encounters something extraordinarily difficult to engineer:


A human being making a judgment about another human being.


And perhaps that is one of the great ironies of our technological age.


We are building machines capable of reasoning across enormous amounts of information.


We are constructing data centers containing extraordinary computational power.


We are creating chips at scales almost unimaginable a generation ago.


We are developing artificial intelligence systems capable of assisting scientists, programmers, governments and corporations.


Yet some of the most important battles over those technologies may still depend on something that existed thousands of years before the first computer:


Whether one human being trusts another.


Which raises a deeper question...


As technology becomes more powerful and more secure, can we ever truly protect it from the ordinary human needs, relationships and vulnerabilities of the people who control it?


Take a moment to reflect.


And click the link below to see more on this subject.


Chatbox_edited_edited.jpg
whatsapp-business-icon.png
Coffee with Heart Design
bottom of page